💌 Forwarded this email? Sign up here and if you have tips or story requests, submit them here.

Loose Threads

  • “Runway” by Lady Gaga and Doechii from The Devil Wears Prada 2 was nominated for a Grammy. I’m a bit pearl-clutchy about this, but Madonna didn’t receive any nominations for Confessions II in the general categories, only in the dance/EDM ones.

  • If you’re not an “I’ll spend $2,100 on Chanel sandal parts” kind of gal (more on those ahead), you can get, well, useful designer items for less. Bezel has a Chanel analog watch (love an analog watch) that looks like a comparative steal. For less than half the price of the sandals, there’s a men’s Cartier Tank or an Omega, if you need a man’s gift (do not love sourcing men’s gifts).

  • Not totally sure what this means, but Balenciaga is hosting a "literary salon" with Substack and it seems to have something to do with the Le City bag, which has basically astroturfed the internet thanks to its 25th anniversary.

  • In happier Balenciaga news, Martine Rose starts this week as creative director.

  • Charlize Theron wore Tom Ford by Haider Ackermann to the Governors Awards red carpet over the weekend.

(Photo: Gilbert Flores/Variety via Getty Images)

Ahead, today’s big story…

The Next Frontier of Dupes?

You’ve probably seen the Bottega Veneta earring dupe, maybe The Row jelly sandal dupe. Surely, you’ve seen the Wirkin (Walmart Birkin). But what about the dupe* of Dior’s famous Junon dress, available to purchase on AliExpress?

Christian Dior's 1949 Junon gown above a lookalike gown sold on AliExpress

Top: Christian Dior's Junon, 1949. Bottom: the AliExpress version.

I noticed a gown that looked like this AliExpress one in a TikTok video of someone who may have been inspired by Wicked (the Broadway musical features a blue dress on Glinda that’s seemingly cribbed from the Junon).

At the time of this writing, AliExpress is only showing four fake Junons sold, but you can also find versions that cost thousands. Nonetheless, seeing this particular dress — only a handful of which were made in 1949 — duped, knocked off, or whatever you want to call it, feels somehow stunning: Dupes typically work best as stand-ins for minimal accessories (while logos are legally protected, apparel designs generally aren’t). The Junon, meanwhile, is among the most rarefied pieces of couture ever made, one of the few fashion artifacts for which “iconic” may be an understated descriptor.

Original Junons belong to the Met and the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco; they’re often shown alongside their sister dress, the Venus. Neither would — hopefully — ever be worn by a human being. Anyone who knows the Junon, one of the most famous iterations of Dior's "New Look" silhouette, likely would not mistake this AliExpress creation for the real thing. “The silhouette’s all wrong, of course. The waist is too high. It’s not strapless,” fashion historian Kimberly Chrisman-Campbell told me.

But dupes have become so commonplace that, according to one study, nearly 60 percent of shoppers have purchased one. TikTok probably has a lot to do with their normalization — according to another study, 60 percent of dupe buyers had an account.

Support Independent Fashion Journalism

Back Row is able to operate thanks to paying members. Join the community to support the independent journalism you find here, and unlock stories like this one:

Dupes and vintage colliding also suggest the celebrity habit of wearing recreations of vintage pieces is starting to trickle down to the average shopper. One appeal of vintage is that it’s “sustainable” — wearing something old keeps an item of clothing in circulation longer instead of fast-tracking its path to a landfill. If dupes become a way for the masses to obtain, say, affordable versions of Zendaya’s greatest red carpet hits, what would that do to our conception of vintage?

In 2022, Kim Kardashian changed how vintage is perceived when she famously wore Marilyn Monroe’s dress on the Met Gala red carpet, apparently damaging it in the process, jumpstarting a vintage-wearing controversy that played out in the news for months. When Dior face Natalie Portman wore a recreation of the Junon at Cannes in 2023, she avoided rousing the same firestorm. Wearing a replica got her and Dior enormous attention and nodded to the original Junon being so special that it can’t ever be worn.

Then, other celebrities did the same. We saw Nicole Kidman wear a flamenco Balenciaga dress remade from an archival piece at the 2024 Met Gala and Ariana Grande in remade vintage Balmain at the 2024 Academy Museum Gala. AliExpress versions of such pieces, of course, won’t fit like remade couture but give the average person a social media moment.

“This idea that we want to wear vintage, but we know it’s bad, led to a rash of these revived archival pieces that were not necessarily from the archive. They were remade for the person, so they fit perfectly. They look amazing. And they’re also not destroying or risking a historic piece,” said Chrisman-Campbell. She called these looks “the gold standard for the red carpet that regular people supposedly can’t do — but now you can.” Nonetheless, mass producing versions of the rarest gowns ever, Chrisman-Campbell added, “kind of cuts the legs out from this idea of archival specialness.”

Chrisman-Campbell also noted the original Venus and Junon were inspired by Roman goddesses Venus and Juno, but not in terms of the fashion associated with them. Rather than being drapey or neoclassical, the designs came from their attributes: A peacock was Juno’s favorite bird, and what many describe as petals on the skirt actually resemble peacock feathers (this is particularly notable in the back). If there’s a concept that transitions seamlessly from 1949 to today, peacocking very well ought to be it.

*I realize “dupe” is a generous term here, but in order to avoid the scare quotes on each mention, just go with it.

Anna Wintour's 'Boy Posse'

Amy Smilovic joined the podcast to talk about how she grew Tibi into the longest running, largest independent fashion brand in America. Tibi does $70 million in revenue without major U.S. department stores and outside investors — and never got Anna Wintour's approval.

Smilovic started in 1997. I asked if she agreed with The September Issue director R.J. Cutler that fashion was a unique business in that you couldn't succeed without Anna's approval (versus, say, film, where you could succeed as a filmmaker without Steven Spielberg's).

"It did feel like that — 100 percent. Everything I did in the beginning was geared towards trying to get into the legacy press," she told me. "We definitely never got acceptance from Anna."

Smilovic felt that, as a woman designer, it was hard to get noticed. “Anna, by the way, loves only the boys. She loves Proenza, Derek Lam, Prabal [Gurung], Alexander Wang, Phillip Lim — like, only the boys. There were just years where it was just Anna and her boys, the boy posse.”

In the full episode, she talks about how Tibi actually lost money by selling in one major department store, gives the story behind the Sid jean (a Back Row reader favorite), talks about New York Fashion Week's supposedly cringiest season, and more. You can also find the episode on Spotify and Apple.

This Gucci Bag Is Now 30 Percent Cheaper Than Before

Obviously things are not going well at Kering, which is wasting away like a red-carpet celebrity on a GLP-1. Gucci has faced declining sales for 13 straight quarters, or more than three years. The last time they had growth, the Eras tour was still new. Things have gotten so desperate that the company has decided to take the previously unthinkable — but totally obvious and necessary — move and cut prices. According to the Wall Street Journal, this bag:

Costs €2,450 today, marked down from €3,500 in July (30 percent!). Louis Vuitton, however, won't cut prices. (Quoth finance chief Cécile Cabanis, "We are not Coca-Cola.")

The Journal calls luxury price cuts "toxic." Fine, it is a total admission that you were just charging for brand and not item, but that was also totally obvious when the prices went up for no apparent reason a couple years ago.

Chanel Sells Pair of Sandal Parts for $2,100

Chanel is taking advantage of its "only white-hot luxury brand in business" status by selling its devotees these "shoes."

According to Instagram posts, they are $2,100. The use case, aside from influencers traipsing around in them at the Hotel du Cap-Eden-Roc, remains unclear.

What Premium Subscribers Are Reading

Amy Odell is the New York Times bestselling author of Gwyneth: The Biography; Anna: The Biography; and the essay collection Tales from the Back Row: An Outsider’s View from Inside the Fashion Industry. Write her at amy (at) amyodell (dot) com. Submit a tip or story request anonymously here.

Partnership inquiries: [email protected]

Back Row may earn commission if you purchase through affiliate links in this newsletter, which helps support the operations of this publication.

Keep Reading